Benny's Pizzeria

845-687-4243
Route 209
Stone Ridge, NY 12484
No photo available for this business

Business Information

Pizza, Restaurants
MasterCard
MONDAY:11:00AM-11:00PM
TUESDAY:11:00AM-11:00PM
WEDNESDAY:11:00AM-11:00PM
THURSDAY:11:00AM-11:00PM
FRIDAY:11:00AM-11:00PM
SATURDAY:11:00AM-11:00PM
SUNDAY:11:00AM-11:00PM

Customer Reviews (13 reviews)

heartonfire

on Citysearch Apr 15, 2010
Yeah This could have been a great place to eat if bennny really made the pizza the people he has working for him suck and are VERY RUDE and cant make a pizza to save there souls! Dont get it delivered it will cost you a arm and... (more)

concernedlocal

on Citysearch Jan 15, 2010
What happened to friendly customer service? (more)

manni22

on Citysearch Sep 24, 2009
gross (more)

specialk0909

on Citysearch Sep 15, 2009
After reading reviews for Benny's I decided to give it a try. When I placed the order, I was given attitude by the young girl answering the phone. I was told the pizza would be here within the hour....an hour and a half... (more)

HLPastry

on Citysearch May 19, 2009
It would seem to me, if you are writing a restaurant review, you should stick to the subject matter and tell of the quality of food you were served and the service you were provided with when you dined at said restaurant.... (more)

LindseyW

on Citysearch Apr 25, 2009
My name is Lindsey and I used to work at Benny's. Benny hired me in January. After working for 2 weeks, he told me that he really liked me and "kept his mind on point" with my witty jokes and good energy. WELL, the next day I... (more)

Citysearch User

on Citysearch Jan 11, 2009
I have always liked the pizza here. I don't live near this restaurant but if I am in the area I am sure to stop and get a pizza to bring ho... (more)

Citysearch User

on Citysearch Sep 26, 2008
lame crust, the marinara tastes like it comes from a can... i was VERY DISAPPOINTED! if you want GOOD pizza take 209 south to Samsonville Rd... (more)

Citysearch User

on Citysearch Jan 13, 2008
I have always enjoyed Benny's pizza as the best in our area. He has now added a beautiful restaraunt in Kingston, serving italian dishes and... (more)

dmanglk

on Citysearch Sep 16, 2007
Good BBQ chicken pizza and salads but is the only resturant I have ever been to that does not have ice! If you order a fountain drink in the middle of a 95 degree hot summer day...you will not get ice. This normally will not... (more)

arthurutc

on Citysearch Feb 09, 2007
The pizza is excellent. The Subs are great too. The turkey breast is roasted onsite and fresh. I highly recommend everything on the menu. The only complaint i have is the pasta dishes that specify linguini come with... (more)

tammyfirmbach

on Citysearch Feb 24, 2006
Benny's Pizzeria is the best pizza in Ulster County. Stop in for a slice or get a hot pie to go you won't be disappointed. I heard they are coming to Kingston and I can't wait. As it is now, I drive from Kingston to Stone... (more)

netochka

on Citysearch Aug 14, 2004
the first time we ate there, it was a quick slice to check the quality. the owner was there, and the pizza was GREAT. we ordered a few pies soon after, and when Benny was the one who handed them over the counter to us, they... (more)

Recent Comments


LOVE, LOVE, LOVE BENNY'S FOOD! This is more than a pizzeria. Everything is fresh, made... (more)
gschust, Feb 20, 2011

Browse our top cities

Browse cities by state