Ye Old Tollgate Steakhouse
Business Information
RestaurantsTraditional American
| MONDAY | : | 12:00PM | - | 3:00PM |
| TUESDAY | : | 12:00PM | - | 3:00PM |
| WEDNESDAY | : | 12:00PM | - | 3:00PM |
| THURSDAY | : | 12:00PM | - | 3:00PM |
| FRIDAY | : | 12:00PM | - | 3:00PM |
| SATURDAY | : | 12:00PM | - | 3:00PM |
| SUNDAY | : | 4:00PM | - | 9:00PM |
Customer Reviews (19 reviews)
PhillyChick
on Citysearch Jun 09, 2009Let me start by saying that this is the first negative review I've ever written about a restaurant, and we eat out a few times a week. To start, while our waiter was very nice and accommodating (the one positive of the... (more)
suesreviews
on Citysearch Dec 05, 2008Sadly disappointed. The waiters hovered and kept rushing us, steaks were way too rare (not what we asked for) and food was way overpriced... (more)
dineout14
on Citysearch Nov 14, 2008Last night was the first night I have been there since the new management has taken over and I must say that the reputation of a Peter Lugers with out the 2 hour drive is well deserved. The presentation of steak as well as... (more)
Rhopki
on Citysearch Nov 01, 2008I took my family to Tollgate Steakhouse last night after reading the reviews on Citysearch. I have to say that I was very disappointed. I am generally an optimist and always find the best in any bad situation, but in the... (more)
lenpoppa
on Citysearch Apr 22, 2006A group of co-workers and I recently made the trip from Stamford CT down to the Tollgate in Mamaroneck...Boy, was it worth the trip...The Portehouse's were excellent, great wine list , all the traditional... (more)
gbrown369
on Citysearch Mar 11, 2006It's not to often that you can come across a great piece of "prime" beef...The quality at the Tollgate is incredible...It's amazing how consistent this steakhouse is...The filet mignon is always so tender, the... (more)
tonystarks
on Citysearch Dec 28, 2005The Tollgate is a classic NYC steakhouse w/ NYC quality serving succulent slabs of "prime beef" and excellent side dishes.By far, the " Best Steak in Westchester"....Plus, a great wine list to compliment the great... (more)
paulwall
on Citysearch Dec 18, 2005An outstanding dining experience from start to finish....Classic Steakhouse atmosphere serving excellent " Prime" beef with all the trimmings....Perfect place for a guys night out...Especially if you book the... (more)
jsimpson1
on Citysearch Dec 15, 2005Perfect atmosphere for a group dinner. From the hearty appetizers, to the delicious poterhouse for 6, cooked to perfection, and accompanied by the traditional steakhouse sides(which I took an extra hasbrown home... (more)
Contributor
on Citysearch Nov 14, 2005Westchester steakhouse with lunch specials, appetizers, extra large T-bones and surf and turf on the menu. (more)
archiecohen
on Citysearch Oct 25, 2005I've been going to the Tollgate for perhaps the last 7-8 years and the I can honestly say I have yet to have a bad meal..The atmosphere is very comfortable , sometimes very loud, but that's why I love it..The steaks , side... (more)
johnhayes
on Citysearch Sep 22, 2005The Tollgate is a no nonsense steakhouse....No trends just beef...I recently had a great time with friends sharing the "signature" steak for four with all the trimmings...Homefries ,spinach , and buttered... (more)
luvtoeatout70
on Citysearch Sep 11, 2005Family owned and managed... Warm friendly staff... Very accommodating... cozy dinning....Party room upstairs... Vallet parking on the weekends. You must try the sizzling bacon over the Caesar Salad. The... (more)
sean131
on Citysearch Sep 07, 2005When a friend told me The Tollgate was " Peter Luger's without the attitude" i couldn't believe it, I had to see for myself.....WOW, I'm happy I did!! From the moment I walked in to the moment I walked out everything was... (more)
mannyzepeda
on Citysearch Sep 07, 2005I was very pleased with the service and the food at Tollgate. The Porterhouse was the best I've had. The sizzling bacon, cream spinach, home potatoes were so yummy. I will definitely patronize Tollgate on a regular... (more)
hoyas2000
on Citysearch Jul 17, 2005I guess the options are small in the steakhouse realm in Westchester, but this wasn't great. Granted it was a couple years ago, but from the other review it sounds like it is the same. We had an o.k. dinner, but to charge... (more)
iamfreenow31
on Citysearch Apr 02, 2004we went on valentines day and i have ti say if it wasnt v-day i wouldve said something- the meat was verrrrrrry fatty overpriced and they sat us in this horrible spot- we asked to move and eventually did but it was the... (more)
lancemanhattan
on Citysearch Mar 08, 2003This restaurant is a great place for your steak. We had a private room upstairs for 16 people ad it was great. Succulent shrimp for appetizers, a huge 4 person porterhouse, creamed spinach, sauteed mushrooms and hash... (more)
dfaccas
on Citysearch Nov 11, 2002A Peter Luger imitation, which slightly lacks Luger's quality. I'd rather go to Flames when I'm in Westchester: the steak, apps and décor are much better (Flames is even better than Luger's).... (more)