Caffe Gelato Restaurant
No photo available for this business
Business Information
Restaurants, Caterers, Banquet RoomsBanquet Rooms
Customer Reviews (137 reviews)
pineaukgp
on Citysearch May 11, 2010Mothers' Day was not the day to visit. In spite of attentive service and good wine the food was fair at best. Side salads were sub par as well as the sides with my wonderful filet. Were those instant potatoes?... (more)
Chef Delaware
on Citysearch Oct 01, 2009Not Enjoyable Very Much Off The Shelf Flavors What Is Up With All These High Rated Reviews? Stuffing of the Ballot Box Perhaps? Ok for a salad I'll Get my dinner elswhere Thanks (more)
Brian188
on Citysearch Jun 16, 2009Caffe Gelato really impressed me with their friendly staff, excellent food, cozy dining room, and overall quality. It was really cool that they make their own gelato right in the restaurant and have so many flavors!... (more)
charleshp11
on Citysearch Jun 16, 2009I recently took my girlfriend to Caffe Gelato for dinner. We sat on the porch and had a great evening. I had the Veal Chop and my girlfriend had one of the pasta dishes. Both were delicious! I highly recommend the porch... (more)
Citysearch User
on Citysearch Mar 17, 2009You can go to this restaurant for a gourmet meal or you can stop by on the way home from the movie for gelato. It rivals the best gelato I'... (more)
Citysearch User
on Citysearch Mar 13, 2009The filet mignon here is absolutely fabulous!! It's so tender; it melts in your mouth. Top it off with a dish of gelato and you've had the... (more)
Diana941
on Citysearch Feb 07, 2009I've been meaning to try Caffe Gelato for a meal (I've stopped by for their wonderful gelato before) and I finally had dinner on Friday night. I was really impressed with the food, and the service and the atmosphere.... (more)
TyHay
on Citysearch Jan 17, 2009I took my girlfriend here for our anniversary. I called 3 days ahead to make a reservation for a quiet/private booth. The said they would and when we arrived they sat us in the second table from the front door. It was so... (more)
Citysearch User
on Citysearch Dec 01, 2008The lunch is to die for! the Panini's are absolutly amazing...appetizers...everything! I've heard their brunch is great too! Dinner was not ... (more)
Citysearch User
on Citysearch Nov 25, 2008The gelato is absolutely amazing! I couldn't get enough. The portions are generous, but the gelato is a bit pricey. However, it is definitel... (more)
Eric201
on Citysearch Oct 18, 2008I took my girlfriend here for our 2 year anniversary, and I was very surprised at how classy this place was. The atmosphere was very romantic...loved the candles in the walls. It looked very new, and for such a classy... (more)
TerriBurchell
on Citysearch Oct 15, 2008I came here for lunch...the paninis are SO good. I was amazed at how good it was...definitely worth the price. I also got gelato at the end, and it was the best ice cream I have had in a while. It was the absolute perfect... (more)
Citysearch User
on Citysearch Sep 30, 2008Food, drink and dessert are all fabulous at this restaurant in the heart of Newark's college town. If you are visiting for a U of D game mak... (more)
ChrisBolton
on Citysearch Sep 15, 2008I have never been one to go onto the internet and write reviews, but I feel that Caffe Gelato needs to receive the recognition it deserves. My fiancee and I recently dined at Caffe Gelato and I have to say that it was one of... (more)
katkrazy
on Citysearch Jun 23, 2008We have visited Caffe Gelato twice. Our first experience was fantastic. The service was excellent and the food was delicious. Our experience Saturday was less than satisfactory. While the food was still delicious... (more)
carollee81
on Citysearch May 12, 2008My husband and I had Caffe Gelato cater our son's First Communion party at our house. They brought everything they needed, even the chef and servers! We had alot of family from out of town and they loved the food and... (more)
hugo101
on Citysearch May 01, 2008My wife and I and our friends thoroughly enjoyed the wine dinner held in honor of Thomas Jefferson. The speaker was excellent. I highly recommend attending a future wine dinner night.... (more)
JordanDeMaio
on Citysearch Apr 18, 2008As an extablishment trying to portray itself as "fine dining", Caffe Gelato should look within itself and embrace all that comes with this title. Attempting to cover up bad or unfavorable reviews on their own... (more)
ghks
on Citysearch Apr 15, 2008My boyfriend and I went out to dinner and had never been to this place. It was very nice inside, and I had recently heard that an addition had been added. The place was beautiful, awesome candles in the wall and... (more)
wert01
on Citysearch Apr 15, 2008I TOTALLY RESCIND MY OPINION REGARDING CAFE GELATO. RYAN, THE OWNER, THROUGH HIS DEDICATION TO GREAT CUSTOMER SERVICE AND OWNERSHIP, MADE THE PAST SITUATION RIGHT. HE IS TO BE COMMENDED. HE WENT ABOVE AND BEYOND TO... (more)
Citysearch User
on Citysearch Apr 09, 2008Gelato is in the tittle, so expect the best! They also offer delicious food, and a good wine selection. Mid range prices, great people w... (more)
LoyolaGreyhounds
on Citysearch Apr 05, 2008While the dinners and lunches at Cafe Gelato are extremely tasteful, their best "hidden" gem is definitely their Sunday brunch. It is reasonably priced and tastes delightful! It is not you typical brunch, rather a... (more)
DukeofDelaware
on Citysearch Mar 06, 2008Cafe Gelato is my preferred lunchtime restaurant in Newark. Prices are very affordable and there is never any waiting for a table. The Panini sandwiches are the best you will get anywhere in Delaware and the same can... (more)
mmb0486
on Citysearch Mar 01, 2008Caffe Gelato is far and above the top restaurant in Newark and the surrounding area. The restaurant offers Northern Mediterranean cuisine, with lots of pasta, seafood, and meat entrees. One previous review cited... (more)
bluehenfan
on Citysearch Feb 17, 2008Caffe Gelato continues to be our favorite place to visit for a great meal and relaxing, candle-lit atmosphere. The recent expansion of the dining area is beautiful and has allowed for more spacious seating, while... (more)
jossd
on Citysearch Feb 17, 2008Wow. Caffe Gelato has pretty much the best gelato all around. There is an entire display case filled with about 24 different types of gelato, from raspberry, to my personal favorite, baccio (a chocolate hazelnut).... (more)
melmmm
on Citysearch Feb 17, 2008We went to Gelato on Saturday night and had Valentines Day dinner. They do a special menu for a few days in a row so you don't have to out on one of the most busy nights of the year, what a great idea. Every thing was great from... (more)
Anderson9
on Citysearch Feb 15, 2008I went to Caffe Gelato on Main Street with a group of friends earlier this week. The menu has been recently updated with the expansion of the restaurant. We sat on the new side and tried some new menu items. The service... (more)
ams1048
on Citysearch Feb 15, 2008It's always a pleasant experience @ Caffe Gelato. The food is consistently excellent, the waitstaff is attentive, and the owner Michael is visible and available ensuring that his guests are pleased. Get on the... (more)
tobyandtjay
on Citysearch Feb 15, 2008My husband and I enjoy a night at Caffe Gelato. The quaint, intimate atmosphere sets it apart from the cookie cutter franchise restaurants in the area. If you have the opportunity to dine on Friday or Saturday night... (more)
Soccermom23
on Citysearch Feb 14, 2008I have been to caffe Gelato several times over the past years with my husband and never before have I been so impressed. The renovation that was recently completed is gorgeous with a great new bar. The service was... (more)
ruecler
on Citysearch Feb 14, 2008We've been going to Caffe Gelato since the month it opened! Each and every time the food has been superb. The menu varies with the season. Just recently I was there with a friend and the service was fabulous as always.... (more)
horsehoe
on Citysearch Jan 14, 2008I had dinner at Caffe Gelato last night with a couple of friends. We have been to this restaurant at least 6 times previously. The menu is the same all the time.....I haven't been there for 1 year and really expected to... (more)
joanbiker
on Citysearch Oct 21, 2007The food at Cafe Gelato is great, but the best thing about it is their homemade Gelato for dessert! If you don't have room after you've eaten a meal there, be sure to take some home for later. You won't regret it!... (more)
ginav87
on Citysearch Aug 05, 2007If you haven't been to Caffe' Gelato yet, you're missing the hidden treasure in Newark for gelato, brunch, an upscale lunch without the upscale price or a nice dinner out. I've done all, but was there last month for... (more)
mmullens1219
on Citysearch Aug 02, 2007I am a lover of Italian food and culture. Having visited Italy many times, I am always on the lookout for new and exciting Italian food. At Cafe Gelato, I found classic recipies with a modern twist. At my last visit I had... (more)
smukherj2002
on Citysearch Jul 11, 2007The Tiramisu at Cafe Gelato was the best Tiramusi I've had ever. Having dessert in a fine dining environment was awesome. Very friendly wait staff, even though we went there only for dessert. I will go there again,... (more)
newark12901
on Citysearch Apr 28, 2007Caffe Gelato is one of the most unique restaurants I have ever eaten at. The plates always come out looking like art, at first you'll be afraid to take a bite, as to not destroy it, but then you do and it?s so good you cannot... (more)
jwplaw
on Citysearch Apr 13, 2007Title says it best from the gelato to the tiramisu to the full wine lists the pairing are wonderful!! This is a must do location when in Newark. Dont' miss it! (more)
gjusiewicz
on Citysearch Mar 25, 2007Very interesting menu items. It is not something you are going to get at the restaurant down the street. The service was great. We had a party of 9. Despite being a small restaurant, they were able to accomodate us and... (more)
luckymeadows34
on Citysearch Feb 13, 2007It all happened because of the winter storm. Our plans were adjusted accordingly....and delightfully so. Gelato's is always high on our list of places to go, so despite the icey and snow covered roads, we decided to... (more)
subtlesandy
on Citysearch Jan 28, 2007I was looking forward to eating at Cafe Gelato because of al the favorable reviews I've read, so I went to lunch during Newark's Restaurant Week. It was very disappointing. The soup, a potato with truffle, was very... (more)
cbs2911
on Citysearch Dec 10, 2006This restaurant is fantastic! Whether you like sandwiches, steak or pasta, you are in for a treat here. Service is superb and the atmosphere is cozy and charming, if a little loud at times. Definitely worth checking... (more)
machpl
on Citysearch Nov 26, 2006Caffe Gelato looks like it was taken from Italy and re-located in Delaware. Not only was the food suberb but presentation, decour, and service were top notch as well. One of the few places that excels in the dining... (more)
lukych3264
on Citysearch Nov 07, 2006Everything about this place was wonderful!! Great food!! Great service!! Very highly recommended. We ordered steak and a pasta dish. There was so much food we had to bring half home. The atmosphere is not quiet and... (more)
romrod
on Citysearch Sep 27, 2006I have never been at a place where everything was perfect. The Wait staff was excellent, the food was beyond amazing in taste,presentation,and served at just the right time. It was the best experience I have had at a... (more)
cmckeon
on Citysearch Sep 26, 2006Cafe Gelato has great food that is different from anything else you can find in Newark! I particularly like this place for Sunday brunch. They have excellent, fast, and friendly service. It's definitely a must try!!... (more)
ksheck
on Citysearch Sep 10, 2006Have dined many times for dinner and brunch. Food is always good and entree specials add to the standard menu. Small, intimate dining room on Newark Main Street usually crowded which shows customers return for... (more)
mtroegler
on Citysearch Sep 05, 2006Great intimate place for dinner. Good value (food vs price). Excellent house salads, nice wine menu, BEST scallops & risottos, excellent pasta pesce special. GREAT PROMOTIONS. Love the wine dinners (good price -... (more)
candycepizzala
on Citysearch Sep 03, 2006We chose our wedding date over a delicious dinner on the patio at Caffe Gelato and planned our dinner reception there for 6 months later. Our reception was perfect from start to finish - from the appetizers and wine... (more)
mangelil
on Citysearch Sep 02, 2006I went with a group of 4 and it was a fantastic experiance. From the food to the wine selections, everything was perfect. The price was great and so was the service. (more)
theresavs
on Citysearch Aug 31, 2006My husband and I have eaten several lunches here and have always had a hard time deciding what to order. Their daily specials have always been tastey, and yesterday was no exception. We both ordered the tomato and crab... (more)
lovemaui
on Citysearch Aug 27, 2006I have had the pleasure of dining at Cafe Gelato for both lunch and dinner. The level of service I experienced at the dinner service was top notch - the type of service I had only experienced at the finest restaurants and... (more)
kidsbooklover
on Citysearch Aug 26, 2006Love the menu, unique pasta dishes, cozy atmosphere, great service. Be sure to get on their email lists and share your birthday and anniversary--they have great, creative marketing programs which just serve to... (more)
hpmorneau
on Citysearch Aug 22, 2006A casual yet upscale dining environment that features a different menu on each visit filled with wonderful choices. Wine tasting specials are outstanding! (more)
ellen19350
on Citysearch Aug 21, 2006Caffe Gelato has the best food in this college town. A special occasion place with wonderful gelato to boot. (more)
mkwms
on Citysearch Aug 21, 2006Every time I go to Cafe Gelato I have a great time. Wait staff is the best. The owner is always there and he makes sure your dining experience is the best you ever had. Cafe Gelato is also a very community conscience... (more)
anthony844
on Citysearch Aug 19, 2006stopped in for Sunday Brunch. They have a nice variety of options to chose (breakfast, sandwiches, or a combination of breakfast and lunch options.) My group had sandwiches and we all were very happy with... (more)
lrem1318
on Citysearch Aug 16, 2006This restaurant is great for a night out or even for lunch because its location is great. You are able to watch everyone walk up and down Main Street in the quaint town of Newark, DE. The food is delicious and presented... (more)
mirniewarrior
on Citysearch Aug 14, 2006My husband and I absolutely love Caffe Gelato!! We got hooked with a group of friends and go to most of the specialty wine dinners. We've also visited for birthday celebrations. The owners and staff create a... (more)
itismejp
on Citysearch Aug 13, 2006Caffe is a FABULOUS place to dine! My husband and I (and friends of ours) eat there ALL the time. Casual, Elegant, just for fun...you name it Caffe Gelato has it. The prices are great and the food is to die for.... (more)
kathysail
on Citysearch Aug 13, 2006We love Caffe Gelato,the food, the wine,the atmosphere,the service. Everything comes together for a great meal and a great night out.The wine dinners are the best.Keep it up Ryan.We can't stay away. I also think you... (more)
virginiagirl98
on Citysearch Aug 12, 2006I absolutely love this place. Caffe Gelato is one of the best places I have ever had the pleasure of dining. First, it has a wonderful location, in the heart of Downtown Newark, Delaware. They have a huge parking area... (more)
gmzanella
on Citysearch Aug 11, 2006I have a big problem with this restaurant. While I admit that the food is very good, I have had constant problems with both the management and the staff. Ryan, the owner, is very rude to customers and has the "I don't need... (more)
janiceltaylor
on Citysearch Aug 11, 2006Caffe Gelato is the place to go for a nice night out in your home town. Come with me to a wine or beer dinner and enjoy thoughtful service, delectable dishes and flowing glasses of cheer to toast new friends and old,... (more)
starboard92
on Citysearch Aug 10, 2006We celebrate our birthdays and anniversary at Caffe Gelato, as well as other times we are looking to enjoy a wonderful meal in and intimate setting or a tasty lunch to break up the work day. Our children (8 & 4) enjoy the... (more)
bmattingly
on Citysearch Aug 09, 2006Caffe Gelato has the classiest food you'll find anywhere in Newark. The staff will also take the time to explain things to you (ingredients, etc) w/o acting as if you are imposing on them by asking a question. The food... (more)
bothen
on Citysearch Aug 09, 2006I am never disappointed when I visit Caffe Gelato. The food, the service, the staff......all wonderful! The cuisine is always unusual and delicious....something new everytime I go. I would recommend this... (more)
cma1975
on Citysearch Aug 08, 2006Having lived and traveled in Italy, my husband and I ate A LOT of food and gelato. It was hard to find an Italian restaurant in DE that even came close to that expereince. Needless to say, we found that here. Good food,... (more)
tombec
on Citysearch Aug 08, 2006my husband and i love caffe gelatto. we were married in italy and enjoy dining here as the gelatto is authentic and a lovely reminder of a beautiful country. the wine selection is spectacular...enjoy the half price... (more)