Business Information
RestaurantsMasterCard
Customer Reviews (20 reviews)
stumpr54
on Citysearch May 18, 2009Called at 7:30 pm on 5-16-09 (Saturday) for reservations that evening. Informed that earliest seating would be 8:15 pm. Accepted the time and arrived around 8:20 pm, waiting 20 minutes to be seated. Ridiculous!!!!... (more)
birdie12541
on Citysearch Mar 08, 2009This was my first trip to Jerry's Old Town. It was a disappointment. I don't understand what all the fuss is about. We had reservations and still had to wait 30 minutes to be seated. The dining room was terribly noisy. We... (more)
JLeighA
on Citysearch Feb 20, 2009The food is, without a doubt, excellent. I have eaten there many times. The waitstaff service is also excellent. The problem is with the management/owner. We were there a week ago, and there was an incident that was... (more)
Boothie8739
on Citysearch Nov 12, 2008We just got back from eating at Jerry's Old Town Inn. We had reservations for 5:30 PM, but really didn't need them (because of the time). It was a very nice experience. On Thursdays, they have an all you care to eat BBQ... (more)
emreg
on Citysearch Oct 01, 2008any employees or ex-employees know the recipe for the French Onion soup and the Original BBQ Sauce? If so, please email them to me at emregister@yahoo dot com Thanks! (more)
emuchik
on Citysearch Aug 29, 2008A close family member worked there and I was appalled to hear that kitchen workers are not given lunch breaks or any kind of break. They are expected to work on their feet in the super hot , disgusting, ant ridden kitchen... (more)
lalaC
on Citysearch Jul 17, 2008A group of only 5 just returned home from dinner and I guess we should have paid attention to the many people who told us to NOT go to dinner at Jerry's. We have ate at Jerry's a number of time and sure we have had to wait. Good... (more)
Jo19
on Citysearch Apr 10, 2008I Don't know where the 2 boneheads that just reviewed Jerry's came from or if they ever get out much but I dine at many high end restaurants and Jerrys, by far, has the best ribs ever. Yes, it is a busy place, but would you... (more)
Crasso
on Citysearch Mar 21, 2008I don't understand the hoopla over these ribs. The people who say they have eaten ribs all over the world and these are the best must be stopping at the wrong places. Don't get me wrong. These are good ribs, but I have had... (more)
Citysearch User
on Citysearch Jan 25, 2008I have ordered from here many many times..sometimes the orders have been screwed up so i call and tell them.. ..Thats not my mistake they make it wrong..I ordered some onion rings (they dont taste as good as the other... (more)
Affinity30
on Citysearch Jan 25, 2008The owner does not stand up for the food he serves even though it is made wrong when it is purchased..And he also tells you not to order from there anymore which is really nice to say to a customer that has a... (more)
jo
on Citysearch Sep 19, 2007Food and service are better than ever! I had a filet with ribs that was to die for. Not to mention the best french onion soup ever! We were glad that we made a reservation since they were packed. We ended our meal with a "Pig... (more)
Citysearch User
on Citysearch Sep 17, 2007went on a Friday night several months ago for the famous ribs..we walked away very disappointed. The ribs were chewy and not flavored the way they were several years ago. I understand that the restaurant is under new... (more)
Citysearch User
on Citysearch Oct 02, 2005Many famous people have frequented this historic place in Germantown. The selection of imported beers is great, the atmosphere is awesome. Get a bib wrapped around you when you order ribs. The ribs come with a bucket... (more)
johnmnz
on Citysearch Jul 31, 2005Great food and even better beer. Over 100 beers to choose from. Service is prompt but not rushed and the food is great - some of the best ribs I've had though the Pork Etoufee was also brilliant. I preferred the Von... (more)
kerturner
on Citysearch Jun 10, 2005Jerry's has the best ribs I have ever tasted! The service is phenomonal, the atmosphere is relaxed, casual and fun. Compared to downtown Milwaukee restaurants, Jerry's is a much better value on price, quality and... (more)
trutz
on Citysearch Jul 13, 2004Excellent ribs. Best in town. Sauce is one of king, unlike Saz's tastes like it's out of the bottle. The French Onion soup is unbelievible. I normally go for the shredded onion rings, but Jerry's fat ones are great... (more)
billybuell10
on Citysearch Jul 13, 2004I travel all over the country and have tried the ribs in many places. I can honestly say Jerry's Old Town wins HANDS DOWN!!! Combine the ribs with the rest of the wonderful menu..try the french onion soup.... and you... (more)
scnmchn
on Citysearch Jul 13, 2004The service is wonderful!!!! In winter the fireplace is lit, creating nice ambiance. Definetly call ahead or you will have a pretty good wait for an open table. This is one of the few places my family will go to for... (more)
Contributor
on Citysearch Oct 22, 2003<b>The Scene</b><br>Paper bibs, wet-naps, and stainless steel bone-buckets attempt to keep patrons clean, but whether sauced with smoky "Original," spicy Cajun, or sweet Jamaican, you'll leave with a little... (more)